Main menu


Workers in these states would pay the most under Biden's new business tax

Where will President Joe Biden and Congressional Democrats get the money to significantly increase subsidies for green energy and expand Obamacare subsidies to the upper middle class?

The short answer is “from hardworking taxpayers”.

Taxpayers of all income levels should expect to end up paying the deceptive name of the left-wing “Inflation Reduction Act.”

However, the new tax will be significantly lower in certain industries and in some parts of the country. The biggest tax in the bill, a new “minimum book tax,” accounts for $222 billion of his projected over $5 trillion in new tax collections. A minimum tax on books would hit manufacturing disproportionately.

According to a recent government estimate by the Joint Taxation Commission, manufacturing will pay 49.7% of the minimum book tax despite making up only about 11% of the economy.

More specifically, the bipartisan commission estimated that 16.1% of the tax would go to chemical manufacturers and 6.9% to manufacturers of transportation equipment (mainly automobiles).

Senate bill amendments may have reduced the tax burden on manufacturers somewhat since the commission released these estimates. However, even using conservative estimates, manufacturing is likely to bear at least 2.5 times the tax burden as compared to the sector’s size as a share of the economy.

Foreign manufacturers are not subject to the new tax unless they have significant business in the United States. Therefore, in order to remain globally competitive, US manufacturers will face pressure to cut labor costs or scale back their operations in the US. This means fewer jobs and lower wages in US manufacturing.

Because of the state’s large manufacturing base, workers in Indiana, Wisconsin, Michigan, North Carolina, and Kentucky will bear the biggest economic hit from the new tax. Manufacturing accounts for approximately 26.6%, 18.9%, 18%, 17.1%, and 17.4% of the economies of these five states, respectively.

U.S. manufacturing employment declined by about 33% between 2000 and 2010. Since then, the steep decline in manufacturing has rebounded slightly, but manufacturing employment is still more than 25% below its 2000 level.

Combined, Indiana, Wisconsin, Michigan, North Carolina, and Kentucky have lost more than 1 million manufacturing jobs since 2000. Total private-sector employment in Indiana, Wisconsin and Michigan fell 7.5% over the period, largely due to a significant loss of manufacturing jobs.

New taxes won’t help America’s manufacturing states.

The proposed minimum book value tax would be a parallel tax regime that would be levied on most large corporations based on the “book value income” in their financial statements.

Business taxpayers must calculate their tax liability twice instead of once. One is based on ordinary taxable income and the second is based on financial statement income.

Although the minimum book tax rate is lower than the federal corporate tax rate (15%), the minimum book tax rate does not allow businesses to claim certain business deductions that are permitted under ordinary corporate taxes.

Due to income limits, the minimum book tax is imposed on capital-intensive sectors such as manufacturing, which often require large operations to achieve the economies of scale necessary to compete in the global economy. It will hit you disproportionately.

The difference between financial statement accounting and conventional tax accounting in the timing of income “realization” and when deductions can be claimed causes business taxpayers to arbitrarily owe the minimum amount of tax on their books in a few years.

As just one example, under book income tax, companies cannot use net operating losses incurred before 2020. Of course, there are many reasons why a company may suffer tax losses in a particular year. This includes high initial start-up costs. to pandemic-related government lockdowns. As such, tax law allows taxpayers to carry forward losses from previous years to offset current taxable profits.

Consider a company that suffered taxable losses in 2018 and 2019 from purchasing expensive factory equipment in those years. The company hopes to eventually offset the cost of its investment and bring higher profits in the years to come.

The COVID-19 shutdown may have delayed future profits, and under Biden’s tax minimum on the books, the company would be on the hook for tax returns, even though it’s still in a net loss since its 2018-2019 investment. You may have to initiate a payment.

Many manufacturers increased their investments in 2018 and 2019. This is thanks to federal tax laws that remove barriers to business investment. The tax cuts and full expense provisions of the Jobs Act of 2017 would allow businesses to fully pay for expenses such as machinery and equipment in the year the capital was purchased and services commenced, rather than in a period that could last 20 years. could be deducted.

Or at least these manufacturers thought they could fully deduct those costs.

With Biden’s tax minimum on the books, Uncle Sam will take away some of the capital allowances borne by companies with unutilized net operating losses.

The timing of the new tax is disappointing. From 2023 to 2027, he said, a full cost-sharing phase-out is imminent, but will only make the U.S. tax environment worse for capital-intensive companies such as manufacturers and traditional energy companies. Rising interest rates and borrowing costs also make it more difficult for manufacturers and other businesses to invest and grow.

But it’s not all bad news for manufacturers. While many manufacturers will face new taxes under the Biden Act, companies that make solar panels, wind turbines, batteries, and parts for electric vehicles will face new tax subsidies and dramatically You will receive access to an expanded federal loan program. Reduction Act,” Washington lobbyists in their industry and, ultimately, your wallet.

The federal government is long past the task of picking winners and losers. For the past few years, your success or failure in America has depended heavily on what your government is doing for you or against you.

Sadly, this latest law is the same. Some more government handouts. Increased taxes, lost jobs, lower wages, more IRS audits of him left.

This work was originally published in The Daily Signal